>> Julia Jacobs, The New York Times
Published: 2019-09-12 20:20:50 BdST
“They’re missing a lot of stuff,” Knight, who was raised Muslim in the East Flatbush neighbourhood, thought. “There were hardly any images of Muslims in their archives. They didn’t have that many images of black people.”
“The archive of Brooklyn isn’t necessarily representing Brooklyn,” she concluded.
Recently, that has changed drastically.
Oral historians associated with the Brooklyn Historical Society spent last year traversing the borough, recording interviews with dozens of Muslims. The intention was to preserve the conversations to fill what the institution admits was a gaping cultural hole in its famous archives.
They collected 54 oral histories, which amount to over 100 hours of audio, publishing the conversations online for public listening. Many interview subjects were born and raised in Brooklyn. Others immigrated here from countries that include Pakistan, Morocco, and Trinidad and Tobago.
They come from a variety of religious sects, including Sunni, Shia and the Nation of Islam. They discuss everything from the social dynamics in their families, marriages and mosques to the repercussions after the Sept 11 attacks and the most recent presidential election.
On Saturday, the Brooklyn Historical Society opened a sound-and-art exhibition drawn from the oral history project that includes a series of black-and-white geometric prints by Brooklyn artist Kameelah Janan Rasheed. The installation is titled “An Opening,” a reference to the first chapter of the Quran, called Surah Al-Fatiha.
But engineering a space for viewers to explore the exhibition independently while listening to intimate interviews posed a technological challenge, Rasheed said.
Outside the sound and art installation, "An Opening," the Brooklyn Historical Society has a display that takes visitors through key historical moments for Muslims living in New York, at the Brooklyn Historical Society, Sept 6, 2019. Oral historians associated with the historical society recorded interviews with dozens of Muslims in the borough during the last year, preserving the conversations to fill what the institution admits was a gaping cultural hole in its famous archives. (Christopher Gregory/The New York Times)
“It’s like you’re tuning channels on a radio,” Rasheed said. “The goal is to invite people to linger in some places, but to give people the option of doing a survey of the space.”
Rasheed, 34, chose stories that drew her in. At one print, a Brooklyn-born man in his 40s discusses the uniquely African American Muslim tradition of the bean pie. At another, a woman recalls a childhood in which everyone in her social circle was Muslim, making her feel as if she grew up in a “Muslim country.”
Because the storytelling in the oral histories is anything but linear — the narratives tend to stop and start and jump around throughout the person’s life — Rasheed reflects that concept in her exhibition, which often travels off the frame and into the space in between the prints.
Rasheed, who grew up in East Palo Alto, California, was raised by parents who converted to Islam. She is particularly drawn to narratives about Muslim history and identity that don’t often get mainstream attention, like the story told by Knight, who was ultimately interviewed for the project, and spoke of celebrating the Eid festivals, two important Muslim holidays, in Prospect Park as a child.
“There’s an assumption of a homogeneous Muslim identity,” Rasheed said. “As a person who grew up in an African American family and who is also Muslim, people forget that we exist at all.”
The exhibition is a piece of a broad effort by the Brooklyn Historical Society to create an archival presence of Muslims, who are about 4% of the borough’s population, according to a 2016 analysis by the Public Religion Research Institute.
Deborah Schwartz, president of the Brooklyn Historical Society, said that the institution was established in 1863, and for over a century the archives mostly reflected the backgrounds of the white men who founded it.
A person listens to audio from a Muslim oral history project while viewing works by Kameelah Janan Rasheed in the exhibition "An Opening," at the Brooklyn Historical Society in New York, Sept 6, 2019. Oral historians associated with the historical society recorded interviews with dozens of Muslims in the borough during the last year, preserving the conversations to fill what the institution admits was a gaping cultural hole in its famous archives. (Christopher Gregory/The New York Times)
Throughout the last two decades or so, she added, the organisation has made a concerted effort to fill those gaps.
The idea for this project came from Zaheer Ali, a scholar of Muslims in the United States, who was hired as the society’s resident oral historian in 2015 and drew on his ties to Muslims in Brooklyn to compile an extensive list of potential interview subjects.
There was a point where Schwartz said she and other staff members questioned whether the project was still viable. It was when President Donald Trump won the 2016 election after proposing to ban Muslim immigration to the country. Schwartz said some Muslims in New York City had serious concerns about surveillance in their communities; others were worried about losing their immigration status.
But after consulting the board of trustees, she said, “We all agreed it was perhaps more important than it even started out as.”
“We wanted to make sure that people felt some sense of trust,” Schwartz said, “that if they were going to lend us their stories, that they understood this was a responsible, safe place to talk about their lives.”
The “Muslims in Brooklyn” project became much more than a collection of interviews that would be tucked away in the institution’s archives. The historical society organised community listening sessions for the interviews and developed a free educational curriculum for schools. A second art exhibition at BRIC House, opening on Friday, presents the work of eight artists (including Knight) and focuses on “multiple dimensions of the contemporary Muslim experience.”